[Verse 1]
Why didn't I listen to my heart
When she had me guessin' from the start
More and more I wonder
Why do I still want her
After all the love I gave to you
All this pain and all because of you

[Chorus]
What am I supposed to do
When it's all a lie
Where am I supposed to go
When it's dark outside
What am I supposed to do
When it's all a lie
Lie to me [6X]
One last time

[Verse 2]
Still had those letters from last fall
And everytime the phone rings
Wish it was your call
More and more I wonder
Why do I still want her
After all the love I gave to you
All this pain I'm in because of you

[Chorus]
What am I supposed to do
When it's all a lie
Where am I supposed to go
When it's dark outside
What am I supposed to do
When it's all a lie
Lie to me [6X]
One last time

[Bridge]
Why did you have to hurt (to hurt)
Loved you for all your lies (your lies)
One thing I know is true
Ill never stop
Lovin' you (lovin' you)
So tell me

[Chorus]
What am I supposed to do
When it's all a lie
Where am I supposed to go
When it's dark outside
What am I supposed to do
When it's all a lie
Won't you lie to me lie to me baby
Lie to me lie to me baby
Won't you lie to me baby
One last time